Mass Arrests on the Brooklyn Bridge> Is This What Democracy Looks Like?

by Nathan Schneider   Published October 1, 2011   Nation of Change

This was the second major Saturday march halted by a mass arrest, largely on account of obstructing traffic.

Article image

News is by now get­ting around that today there were mass ar­rests of Oc­cupy Wall Street pro­test­ers—700 or more—on the Brook­lyn Bridge. As over a thou­sand marchers made their way to­ward the bridge a few min­utes after 3 p.m., they split into two groups. Some fol­lowed mem­bers of the Di­rect Ac­tion Com­mit­tee who led the way up the el­e­vated pedes­trian walk­way in the mid­dle of the bridge. An­other group, how­ever, broke away and took to the Brook­lyn-bound road on the bridge’s south side, even­tu­ally fill­ing the whole road­way so that no traf­fic could get through. The front row of them locked arms and pro­ceeded. At first, po­lice had blocked nei­ther en­trance.

Be­fore the marchers on the road­way reached the first stone tower, and hav­ing been led by a pha­lanx of se­nior po­lice of­fi­cers, they were in­ter­cepted from the other side. (Even The New York Times of­fers ev­i­dence that the po­lice may have pur­posely planned to lure marchers into a trap.) Out came dozens of dark-blue shirted of­fi­cers with plas­tic cuffs—ac­tu­ally, card­board boxes full of them. Some of­fi­cers un­rolled the same type of or­ange nets they had used the pre­vi­ous Sat­ur­day to make nearly 100 ar­rests, while oth­ers lined up op­po­site the pro­test­ers, halted them, and began to ap­pre­hend and cuff them, one by one.

For a few min­utes, the scene was very tense, as could be ob­served from above on the pedes­trian walk­way, where hun­dreds more marchers were pass­ing by. On the road­way, there were scuf­fles as some force used against those being ap­pre­hended. “This Is a Peace­ful Protest!” peo­ple chanted. And: “No! Sleep! Till Brook­lyn!“ But soon the whole process as­sumed the ap­pear­ance of rou­tine, and, for those wait­ing to be taken away, of solemn dig­nity.

 At the front and back, with the crowd of marchers on the road­way sur­rounded on three sides by nets, po­lice con­tin­ued cuff­ing them and lead­ing them away, one at a time. Slowly. Most of the marchers sat down and waited. “If you sit down, there is no fear,” called one marcher, each phrase echoed by the oth­ers in the “peo­ple’s mi­cro­phone.” They talked, and smoked cig­a­rettes, sang songs, and chanted. Many smiled as they were led away.

 Mean­while, more po­lice ar­rived on the pedes­trian walk­way, and they used more nets to cor­don off the area di­rectly in front of where the ar­rests were hap­pen­ing. And so it went on and on over the course of hours, as po­lice vans and city buses ar­rived to take away those ar­rested. It started rain­ing—lightly, at first, and then hard.         

The sev­eral hun­dred marchers who had been on the pedes­trian walk­way and had been turned back down to the Man­hat­tan side ral­lied at the base of the bridge. They marched around some in the rain, in­clud­ing to 1 Po­lice Plaza to de­mand the re­lease of their com­rades. Then they de­bated where to go next, and fi­nally agreed to re­turn to Lib­erty Plaza. On the way, they were joined by sev­eral hun­dred more, who had made it to Brook­lyn on the pedes­trian walk­way and re­turned on the Man­hat­tan Bridge. As a mass, to­gether, they all re­turned with a sense of vic­tory to the plaza.

It was dark by then. Din­ner was ready, and they cel­e­brated and started plan­ning the next move.

This was the sec­ond major Sat­ur­day march halted by a mass ar­rest, largely on ac­count of ob­struct­ing traf­fic. One might won­der, how­ever, whether caus­ing such an ob­struc­tion is re­ally the proper mode of civil dis­obe­di­ence given the pur­poses of the protest. It’s help­ful to re­call a maxim of Gene Sharp’s: “Ei­ther you do some­thing you’re not sup­posed to do, or you don’t some­thing you are sup­posed to do.” To put it an­other way: do some­thing good that’s against the law, or refuse to do some­thing bad that the law de­mands of you.

Cre­at­ing such an ob­struc­tion cer­tainly does ful­fill the pur­pose of oc­cu­pa­tion—it is a way of re­claim­ing pub­lic space, of being heard, and of stop­ping busi­ness as usual. But it also ob­structs a lot of peo­ple who are not the protest’s tar­gets. There­fore, this may not be the most ap­pro­pri­ate law to be ar­rested for break­ing—or at least not the one that sends the clear­est mes­sage. To make the mat­ter even more am­bigu­ous, many peo­ple who fol­lowed the crowd and the po­lice onto the road­way prob­a­bly didn’t know that by doing so they were risk­ing ar­rest.

What might be bet­ter? Per­haps some­thing along the lines of Tim DeChristo­pher’s well-known ob­struc­tion of an il­le­gal oil and gas lease auc­tion, for in­stance. In this and other clas­sic cases of civil dis­obe­di­ence, from Gandhi’s salt march, to the sit-ins at seg­re­gated lunch coun­ters, to the Free­dom Rides, to Rosa Parks’ choice of seat on a Mont­gomery bus, re­sisters took care to break the pre­cise laws or rules or cus­toms that they op­posed. Their mes­sage, even with­out hav­ing to say any­thing, was ab­solutely ev­i­dent. Es­pe­cially since many peo­ple com­plain that there isn’t enough clar­ity of mes­sage from Oc­cupy Wall Street, more clar­ity of ac­tion might go a long way to win­ning even more peo­ple to the rapidly-grow­ing cause.

Today, hun­dreds of peo­ple were ar­rested, many surely for the first time. More seem likely to fol­low. The world was watch­ing (in­clud­ing tens of thou­sands on the move­ment’s livestream TV chan­nel), and what it saw were en­tirely peace­ful pro­test­ers, in the streets to op­pose an un­just econ­omy and a cor­rupt po­lit­i­cal order, being ar­rested en masse while bring­ing their mes­sages across one of New York’s great­est land­marks.

WAMMToday is now on Facebook! Check the WAMMToday page for posts from this blog and more! “Like” our page today. You may also subscribe to WAMMToday from the blog website.
By Published On: October 3rd, 2011Comments Off on Mass Arrests on the Brooklyn Bridge> Is This What Democracy Looks Like?

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Subscribe via email
Enter your email address to follow Rise Up Times and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,899 other followers


VIDEO: Militarism, Climate Chaos, and the Environment