A Dark Decade for Civil Rights and Liberties

by Kanya D’Almeida     Nation of Change

Saturday 10 September 2011

The U.S. has a long history of responding to national trauma by restricting rights and ladling out unchecked power to the executive during times of crisis – a pattern that is clearly marked out by the government’s clampdown on individual rights and liberties during the Civil War, the Cold War and World War II.

The tenth an­niver­sary of the at­tacks on the World Trade Cen­ter’s Twin Tow­ers and the Pen­ta­gon on Sep. 11, 2001 is marked by mourn­ing.

With ral­lies planned across the coun­try, largely con­cen­trated at the sites of the twin tragedies in Wash­ing­ton D.C. and Lower Man­hat­tan in New York City, vic­tims’ fam­ily mem­bers and politi­cians will gather on Sun­day to share a solemn mo­ment for those who were killed and maimed on that fate­ful day.

But an­other group of mourn­ers are mak­ing them­selves heard this year, lament­ing more than just civil­ian deaths.

Led by civil rights and ad­vo­cacy or­ga­ni­za­tions like the Amer­i­can Civil Lib­er­ties Union (ACLU), the Cen­ter for Con­sti­tu­tional Rights (CCR) and the Bren­nan Cen­ter for Jus­tice, this group is mark­ing the demise of pre-9/11 democ­racy in the U.S., using the aus­pi­cious day to de­mand restora­tion of basic human and civil rights.  

“We are using this mo­ment to take a step back and ask big, broad ques­tions about how and why the U.S. con­tin­ues to de­fine it­self in a state of per­pet­ual emer­gency, how we seem to be mov­ing to­wards a na­tional se­cu­rity state, rather than re­turn­ing to a proper bal­ance be­tween lib­erty and se­cu­rity,” Ben Wiz­ner, lit­i­ga­tion di­rec­tor of the ACLU’s Na­tional Se­cu­rity Pro­ject and co-au­thor of the union’s newly- minted re­port “A Call to Courage“, told IPS.

Wiz­ner ac­knowl­edged that the U.S. has a long his­tory of re­spond­ing to na­tional trauma by re­strict­ing rights and ladling out unchecked power to the ex­ec­u­tive dur­ing times of cri­sis – a pat­tern that is clearly marked out by the gov­ern­ment’s clam­p­down on in­di­vid­ual rights and lib­er­ties dur­ing the Civil War, the Cold War and World War II, he said.

“But part of that pattern has al­ways en­tailed re­al­iz­ing our mis­takes, ad­mit­ting when we went too far, and at­tempt­ing to re­gain some sort of bal­ance in civil so­ci­ety,” Wiz­ner said, adding that in the decade since 9/11, the op­po­site has been true.

“The dan­ger of defin­ing a war as being against ‘ter­ror­ism’ is that it takes place every­where and may last for­ever, the war it­self be­comes an ab­strac­tion rather than a re­al­ity, and there is no end in sight,” he said.

“After the mas­sive se­cu­rity re­sponse to 9/11, we all thought the pen­du­lum would swing back, but it ap­pears to be going in the same di­rec­tion. De­spite the fear-mon­ger­ing, we haven’t seen mas­sive fol­low-up at­tacks in the U.S., the po­lit­i­cal de­bate is the same as it was 10 years ago, more and more power is being chan­neled to the ex­ec­u­tive and to law en­force­ment and there has been in­creased au­tho­riza­tion of il­le­gal de­ten­tions with­out charge or trial and to the use of lethal force away from tra­di­tional bat­tle­fields,” he con­cluded.

Ac­cord­ing to the CCR, the decade since 9/11 has been used to “shred the U.S. Con­sti­tu­tion, tram­ple on the Bill of Rights, dis­card the Geneva Con­ven­tions, and heap scorn on the do­mes­tic tor­ture statute and the U.N. Con­ven­tion Against Tor­ture and Other Cruel, In­hu­man or De­grad­ing Treat­ment or Pun­ish­ment.”

Haul­ing Pres­i­dent Barack Obama into the spot­light for fail­ing to de­liver on any of his 9/11-re­lated promises, the CCR claimed that Obama “has failed to shut down Guantánamo and to hold the Bush ad­min­is­tra­tion ac­count­able for its war crimes, in­clud­ing tor­ture; (has al­lowed) war in Afghanistan to rage on with no sign of ter­mi­na­tion; and has per­pet­u­ated the prac­tice of ren­di­tion to third coun­tries for in­ter­ro­ga­tion and in­def­i­nite de­ten­tion, when mon­i­tor­ing and ‘diplo­matic as­sur­ances’ can­not pre­vent against tor­ture.”

To com­mem­o­rate the an­niver­sary, the CCR com­piled a data­base of its own clients who have suf­fered from the cli­mate of im­punity and il­le­gal­ity that has reigned for 10 years, in­clud­ing tes­ti­mony from Maher Arar, a Cana­dian cit­i­zen who was tor­tured for a full year in Syria; 17-year-old Mo­hammed Khan Tu­mani, one of the orig­i­nal 22 mi­nors to be de­tained and se­verely abused in Guan­tanamo Bay; and Be­na­mar Be­natta, who spent a total of five years in de­ten­tion and is cur­rently a plain­tiff in a class-ac­tion law­suit against for­mer at­tor­ney-gen­eral John Ashcroft.

Be­natta’s tes­ti­mony reads, “(While) in de­ten­tion, I was un­aware of how far the hor­rors of 9/11 had changed our world. We have let fear and ha­tred get the best of us.”

As se­cu­rity tight­ens around New York and Wash­ing­ton on the eve of the week­end an­niver­sary, a press­ing con­cern on the radar of count­less civil rights ad­vo­cates has been the im­pinge­ment of the state sur­veil­lance ap­pa­ra­tus onto per­sonal pri­vacy.

re­cent re­port by the As­so­ci­ated Press that ex­posed the close work­ing ties be­tween the New York City Po­lice De­part­ment (NYPD) and the Cen­tral In­tel­li­gence Agency (CIA) drew at­ten­tion to some of the de­struc­tive ef­fects of coun­tert­er­ror­ism on local com­mu­ni­ties, par­tic­u­larly the CIA’s prac­tice of de­ploy­ing “au­then­tic” spies into local com­mu­ni­ties for in­for­ma­tion-gath­er­ing pur­poses.

Ac­cord­ing to the AP re­port’s au­thors, “the NYPD [cur­rently] op­er­ates far out­side its bor­ders and tar­gets eth­nic com­mu­ni­ties in ways that would run afoul of civil lib­er­ties rules if prac­ticed by the fed­eral gov­ern­ment… and it does so with un­prece­dented help from the CIA in a part­ner­ship that has blurred the bright line be­tween for­eign and do­mes­tic spy­ing.”

Faiza Patel, co-di­rec­tor of the Lib­erty and Na­tional Se­cu­rity Pro­gram at the Bren­nan Cen­ter for Jus­tice, wrote last week, “The pri­vacy of our homes and our com­mu­ni­ca­tions has been eroded by a range of new mea­sures. These in­clude se­cret ‘sneak and peek’ war­rants that allow the gov­ern­ment to search your home with­out telling you about it until months later and na­tional se­cu­rity let­ters that com­pel banks and In­ter­net ser­vice providers to se­cretly re­veal your per­sonal in­for­ma­tion.”

Crit­ics say that far from mak­ing the coun­try safer, these pro­grams and poli­cies have ac­tu­ally made the U.S. more vul­ner­a­ble, both in its image over­seas and, more im­por­tantly, on a do­mes­tic level.

Ac­cord­ing to Heidi Beirich, re­search di­rec­tor of the South­ern Poverty Law Cen­ter, the post-9/11 cli­mate has seen a rise in hate groups across the coun­try, pos­si­bly one of the most wor­ri­some man­i­fes­ta­tions of a pop­u­la­tion’s in­se­cu­rity.

“There were no spe­cific anti-Is­lamic hate groups be­fore 9/11,” Beirich told IPS.

“Now there are groups solely de­voted to anti-Mus­lim ha­tred, in­clud­ing groups such as Pam Geller’s ‘Stop Is­lamiza­tion of Amer­ica’,” she added, ref­er­enc­ing a group no­to­ri­ous for its Mus­lim-bash­ing that is plan­ning what will un­doubt­edly be a highly racially charged rally in New York this Sun­day.

WAMMToday is now on Facebook! Check the WAMMToday page for posts from this blog and more! “Like” our page today. You may also subscribe to WAMMToday from the blog website.

By Published On: September 11th, 2011Comments Off on A Dark Decade for Civil Rights and Liberties, by Kanya d’Almeida

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Subscribe via email
Enter your email address to follow Rise Up Times and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,899 other followers


VIDEO: Militarism, Climate Chaos, and the Environment